Expert Witness Journal Issue 66 April 2026 - Flipbook - Page 105
•
“no more force and for no longer than is
necessary and proportionate”
•
“Force is avoided for the removal of clothing from
detainees because of risks of self-harm. Other
ways of managing these risks are considered
and force is only used as a last resort. Use of
force within custody suites, and the control
and restraint equipment used, is documented
within the individual custody record. A separate
‘use of force’ form is submitted by each o昀케cer/
sta昀昀 member involved that clearly explains what
happened and why force was used”
•
“When force is used on detainees, their health
needs are considered and they are examined
by an appropriately quali昀椀ed healthcare
practitioner if necessary. Where a detainee asks
to see a healthcare practitioner this is arranged
promptly.”
•
“Any use of force or restraint on a child should
be a last resort, and take their age into account.
When force other than compliant handcu昀케ng
is used, children are always examined promptly
by an appropriately quali昀椀ed healthcare
practitioner”
•
“Use of force incidents in custody are recorded
accurately and reported into the governance
structures. There are quality assurance
arrangements to show that the force used was
lawful and proportionate.”
demonstrate their case and for o昀케cers to defend
themselves. One month retention is a signi昀椀cantly
short period of time for any complainant, PSD or
legal team to be aware of, prepared for, and seeking
retention of the digital footage.
Use of force to remove clothing. I sometimes
see ligature cutters being used in cells to remove
clothing from detainees considered being at risk
of self-harm, but not actively self-harming. Firstly,
a ligature cutter is an emergency rescue device for
ligature incidents and should not be used in these
circumstances. It destroys clothing when alternative
tactical options were possibly available. The custody
expectations state that: “other ways of managing
these risks are considered and force is only used as a
last resort” such as level 3 or 4 observations regimes.
The 昀氀ip side of this point is I do sometimes see a
detainee has been restrained on the cell 昀氀oor and
had their clothes torn from them on the justi昀椀cation
they are a self-harm risk. This being the case they
must be a昀昀orded a level 3 or 4 observation care plan
as they are considered a heightened level of risk
through self-harm/suicide. Level 3 and 4 mandate
the involvement of the Healthcare Professional
(HCP) for a clinical and forensic assessment which
will include the mental health screening assessment
and an appropriate adult assessment, as there are
reasons to suspect the person is mentally vulnerable.
What I often see is the detainee has their clothing
torn from them and then they are placed on a level 1
Each police area custody provision is assessed
against this criteria within every 7 years, and most
forces within the UK are identi昀椀ed with issues
concerning their use of force which include the
lack of governance and oversight of use of force
being inadequate, the lack of custody record entries
justifying the use of force, the lack of use of force
submissions, the lack of preserved digital evidence
from the custody CCTV and o昀케cer body worn video
(BWV); and force being used against detainees
when other tactical options were readily available
and not considered or attempted. The College of
Policing states: “A custody o昀케ce is a controlled
environment and the overriding objectives should
be to avoid using force in custody.” And “Custody
o昀케cers should manage their environment so that
situations where the use of force may be necessary
are de-escalated.”
Digital footage retention. Police forces are typically
now destroying digital footage from custody CCTV
and BWV after 1 month. When I deal with a death
in custody the footage is available as it has been
immediately seized and preserved. The problem
is typically for all other use of force cases. For
example, a complaint is made for excessive use of
force. O昀케cers are served Gross Misconduct papers.
The truth of what occurred is on that footage,
which in many of my cases has now been destroyed.
This makes it equally di昀케cult for a detainee to
EXPERT WITNESS JOURNAL
103
APRIL 2026